Mandatory composting may come to SF
San Francisco wants to boost its high recycling rate, so it may become the first city to make composting and recycling mandatory. And there could be stiff penalties for those who don't comply. Caitlan Carroll reports.
Food for composting is dumped into a truck. (Caitlan Carroll/Marketplace)
More on Sustainability
Links
Boulevard Restaurant's executive chef Pamela Mazzola
Recology CEO Mike Sangiacomo
Waste Reduction Manager Sean Davison.
Property manager Linda Corso
San Francisco resident Michael Kellenbach
TEXT OF STORY
KAI RYSSDAL: I don't know how it works for you, but at my house anyway, it's the blue garbage can for recycling, the green one for yard trimmings and the brown one for trash. Nothing though, for leftover food. Unless you've got a composting heap in your backyard, you throw scraps right in with the regular trash, no? Not so in San Francisco. The city wants to boost its already high recycling rate by making composting mandatory. From the Marketplace Sustainability Desk, Caitlan Carroll explains.
Caitlan Carroll: The Boulevard Restaurant in San Francisco is packed on a Wednesday night. In the kitchen, cooks are juggling pans, grilling fish, and stirring sauces.
Pamela Mazzola: So here's the main line where all the cooking is done.
Executive chef Pamela Mazzola surveys the kitchen as plates of artfully arranged halibut and roasted potatoes make their way to the dining room. When the plates come back:
Mazzola: The waiters come, scrape off the plates. So all table scraps are composted.
Thousands of restaurants, apartments and homes participate in San Francisco's compost program. That's about 70 percent of all San Francisco residents. The city has one of the best recycling rates in the nation. But it's not good enough for Mayor Gavin Newsom. He's pushing a law to make San Francisco the first city to require recycling and composting. He wants to push the recycling rate to 75 percent or beyond.
It's not as easy as it sounds. To get the program started San Francisco had to work out a system with the company that picks up the city's trash. It's called Recology. Recology's CEO Mike Sangiacomo's points out, the waste industry's built on disposing trash, not re-purposing it.
Mike Sangiacomo: Collect it. Put it in the ground. And that's really where the bulk of the industry made its money.
Now Recology has figured out a way to turn food trash into cash. It sells the compost for to vineyards and farms. They're willing to pay $500 a truck load for the compost because it's packed with nutrients.
To get an idea of what a change the compost plan has made to the city's garbage haul, all you have to do is visit the local 44-acre dump. I put on my galoshes, hold my nose and waste manager Sean Davison leads the way.
Carroll: So we're heading into the organics annex?
Sean Davison: The organics annex where all of San Francisco 's food scraps end up where they're collected.
Thousands of birds feast on piles of rotting food.
Davison: You don't have a fear of birds do you?
Carroll: I don't, I don't.
Davison: They don't attack.
All this used to end up in landfills. Now the fish heads and rinds take on a second life as compost. Davison says people like the environmental payoff but they like something else more.
Davison: We would like to think that it's the right thing to do but most of it is financial. When you go to someone and you tell them you could cut your garbage bill in half, you're going to get their attention.
Businesses who recycle can cut their trash bills in half. The garbage companies also make more if they meet recycling goals. San Francisco residents don't get a break on their monthly $25 bill for trash pick up. But if they don't compost and recycle, they could get hit with a fine of $100. Businesses could pay more.
Recology doesn't want to play trash cop. So it's sending out compost and recycling starter kits. Apartment manager Linda Corso has hers.
Linda Corso: We put the posters that we got up over here so when people come down they can sort of look at it.
She likes the compost plan but worries that she could be punished if her tenants' don't cooperate.
Corso: I can't go in and force someone to compost rather than put things in the trash, and I certainly can't sit and go through every bag of trash that gets dumped.
Success will come down to making renters care. Take Michael Kellenbach. He's interested. He just doesn't know what to do.
Michael Kellenbach: I'd want to know what to put in there. I mean do you just put leaves?
Yep.
Kellenbach: Do you put dead flowers?
Sure.
Kellenbach: Do you put coffee grounds?
Yeah, those too. Plus ice cream cartons, cardboard boxes and any leftover food you find.
Other cities are watching San Francisco as the composting plan makes it way through the city government. If it becomes law, composting could become a household habit.
In San Francisco, I'm Caitlan Carroll for Marketplace.
Comments
Comment | Refresh
From Seattle, WA, 05/13/2009
I am not sure about other cities, but Seattle added mandatory food & yard waste collection at the beginning of this year.
And they expanded the waste recycling to include more items, at this time. Its been really great! SF would not be the first.
From AZ, 05/11/2009
I'm in Chandler, AZ and here you can just ask them for a compost kit and they'll drop one on your door step on the next pickup of trash.
It's basically a knee high garbage bin with holes drilled into it plus a booklet on composting.
05/11/2009
Beware trying to pass environmental regulations on individual behavior. Individual regulation is the "3rd Rail" of Environmental law.
People are fine with regulating businesses but if you try to tell individual citizens that they have check their car for pollution, or that they need a 10-foot stack on their outdoor woodburner, beware! You're likely to get the backlash of your lives.
People foam at the mouth when you tell them how they have pay a techician to certify an old refrigerator for dispoasl. It's likely to end up in a ditch somewhere.
From Larksur, CA, 05/10/2009
I live in Marin County, just north of SF. I'd like to know if Recology has a "composting starter kit" or something of that nature, so I can compost, too. I looked on their website and nada. Any help there? Thanks!
05/09/2009
It isn't necessary to inject some small element of chagrin or disappointment over the fact that the composting program presents a financial benefit to its participants. Sending perfectly good organic matter to a landfill is a waste of resources and therefore a waste of money. Conversely, composting is a way to reclaim residual value in organic material, in addition to keeping that organic matter circulating in an ecological cycle. The financial windfall is not some embarrassing side show to the process. It is an integral part, one which we should embrace along with the rest of it.
From huntington beach, CA, 05/09/2009
I love this story and I think it hits on all the right points. In fact, I love it so much I have started a non-profit dedicated to this cause. We are starting in southern california and have the same goals: make it a real business for companies, educate folks on how to do so, and enact permanent change through city ordinances.
Will definitely use this piece in my work and even contact the companies involved.
http://acleanlife.org
From San Francisco, CA, 05/08/2009
I LOVE the SF city compost program! However, as a renter, my landlord would not allow our building to compost because he was afriad it would smell (not to mention my clothesline for the backyard was also verbotten). Now that we bought a house - I can finally compost and clothesline in my backyard.
I hope people around the world listen to this and the hair compost stories and adopt them.
Well done marketplace.
From Coeur d Alene, ID, 05/08/2009
I applaud the effort true it may be driven by money, but its making a step in the right direction no matter the stimulus that got it going. I would hope that many cities would follow suite and implement a similar program.
From HAWTHORN WOODS, IL, 05/08/2009
Waste Reduction Manager Davison's comments were an eye-opener for me as he describes the benefits of the city composting for the environment. Also appreciated his added humor with Caitlin Carroll ("You're not afraid of birds, are you?" Thanks!
Post a Comment: Please be civil, brief and relevant.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. Marketplace reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air if they are extra-interesting. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to American Public Media. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited email and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.