• News/Talk
  • Music
  • Entertainment

Marketplace

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Listen to the show

What's in your DNA?

Graphic from 23 and Me website

A company called 23andMe is now offering a direct-to-consumer genetic testing service. For $999 it will give you a detailed analysis of your DNA. But might that be the very definition of too much information? Ashley Milne-Tyte reports.

Graphic from 23 and Me website (http://www.23andme.com/) (23 and Me)

More on Health, Innovation, Science

TEXT OF STORY

KAI RYSSDAL: The World Economic Forum kicks off tomorrow in Davos, Switzerland. There'll be lots of schmoozing and high-concept panel discussions over the ensuing couple of days. As well as some announcements timed to capitalize on the publicity. A company called 23andMe will introduce a direct-to-consumer genetic testing service for Europeans. It's already available here in the United States. Send them $999 and a swab of saliva, six weeks later you get some pretty detailed analysis of your DNA. But might that be the very definition of too much information?

From New York, Ashley Milne-Tyte reports.


ASHLEY MILNE-TYTE: 23andMe won't tell you how likely you are to develop certain diseases. The company's website says it'll help you read and understand your DNA.

Caroline Lieber: The majority of people don't have any real background in genetics and how to even interpret that information.

Caroline Lieber directs the human genetics program at Sarah Lawrence College. She says the problem with direct-to-consumer genetics tests is that the results may confuse consumers.

Lieber: So that while the 23andMe site has something they call Genetics 101, the concepts are tough and it takes a while for them to sink in and have people understand what they mean.

She says people should consult health professionals to fully understand the implications of their results.

Steven Keiles is president-elect of the National Society of Genetic Counselors. He says it's a good idea to consult a counselor before embarking on a home test.

Steven Keiles: If they were talking to a genetic counselor prior to testing, they would have a much better understanding and expectation which would alleviate the stress that can be caused post-test.

David Mongillo of the American Clinical Laboratory Association likes the idea of home testing. But he says diagnosis should be done in federally approved labs. Right now there's little federal oversight of this business. But Mongillo says too much might be on the way.

David Mongillo: It would be an error to have duplicative and redundant regulatory oversight on these services that will really slow down and maybe even stifle the promise of this whole genetic personalized medicine.

Which, he says, will be a positive force in the delivery of health care.

I'm Ashley Milne-Tyte for Marketplace.

Music From This Show

  • Act Nice and Gentle Black Keys Buy
  • Boom Boom CCS Buy
  • Cause a Scene Ghostland Observatory Buy
  • Watching the Detectives Elvis Costello Buy
  • Disco Rout Legowelt Buy

Marketplace Confessional

"I disagree with Diana Nyad, who told Bob Moon today that Americans are not interested in Wimbledon because there are so few Americans playing. I love watching tennis, no matter who is playing. I have watched tennis for years, but the networks toy with us, creating drama rather than showing the match. Oftentimes, televised matches end precisely when the allotted time expires, even if they have to cut and splice. When they don't, as happened in a Nadal match last weekend, we were left hanging at the end of two sets, as NBC switched to women's golf. I don't have cable TV, so I couldn't switch to MSNBC as was suggested. It's enough to make me turn off the TV and read about the matches online."

The Specials

Conversations from the Corner Office

Marketplace goes one-on-one with CEOs, company founders, head honchos...

Sit in

Working

Intimate profiles of workers in the global economy.

Meet them

Consumer Consequences game

Find out what the world would look like if everyone lived like you. An interactive game from American Public Media.

Play

Marketplace on iTunes U

Marketplace is now available in iTunes U, Apple's online education platform. Get free, downloadable content in subjects like History, Science, Business and more. Study up

Sustainability

What is "sustainability?" It boils down to this: Don't eat your seed corn.

Learn more

 ©2008 American Public Media