McDonald's targets Starbucks attitude
We've been hearing a lot lately about negative TV ads stirring up America's ongoing culture wars. Some new ones are about to come out, not from one political candidate attacking another, but from McDonald's attacking Starbucks. Rico Gagliano reports.
Woman in McDonald's commercial targeted at Starbucks. (McDonald's coffee commercial)
More on Marketing - Advertising, Retail, Food
TEXT OF STORY
TESS VIGELAND: We've been hearing a lot about negative ads over the last few months. Ads stirring up the culture wars in this country. Turning "elite" into a four-letter word. A new spate is about to come out. But not from the usual suspects. Rico Gagliano reports.
RICO GAGLIANO: The ads are airing as local markets roll out McDonald's new "McCafe" premium drinks. The spots are set in Starbucks-esque coffee shops. One features two hipster dudes, the other two stylish urban women.
- McDonald's Premium Coffee Commercial
- (fleddertube / You Tube)
WOMAN 1: You know, I heard McDonald's is making lattes now.
WOMAN 2: McDonald's? Well that's just . . . it's fantastic!
WOMAN 1: Now we don't have to listen to jazz all day long!
WOMAN 2: I can start wearing heels again!
Barbara Lippert is a critic for AdWeek media. She says competitors have poked fun at Starbucks before. But these new ads take things a step further -- to culture war in the coffeehouse.
BARBARA LIPPERT: It really seems to be in the Sarah Palin moment. Because all that is about anti-intellectualism and shootin' and huntin' . . . . And this is, you know, "Oh, we really always hated Starbucks, and thank God for McDonald's and a real American option.
Now, the ads were surely in development long before Sarah Palin hit the scene. And in a statement, McDonald's says it's simply trying to bring in "customers who may not be visiting us today for Premium Coffee."
Still, more than one ad expert makes the connection between the presidential and the McDonald's campaigns.
FAITH POPCORN: It's adapting kinda the campaign approach.
See? Faith Popcorn is CEO of market consultants BrainReserve.
POPCORN: I can't imagine that anybody could fall for this.
GAGLIANO: And yet, time after time, we've seen that people do fall for negative campaigns, you know.
POPCORN: But this is beyond a negative campaign, this is condescending, to say that they're not smart enough to go to Starbucks!
See you at the polls . . . I mean, coffee shop.
In Los Angeles, I'm Rico Gagliano for Marketplace.
Comments
Comment | Refresh
From taxas, GA, 11/19/2008
!!!!! HEY HEY HEY ITS CHRISTMAS BONAZA......WE ARE ON PROMO....BUY WITH DISCOUNTS...BUY 3 UNITS GET 1 FREE...WITH LOT OF GIFTS......GET YOUR OWN NOW.....WE SERVE CUSTOMERS BETTER TO THEIR SATISFACTION......
We have all the items available for sale now, if you are interested in purchasing any one of them,kindly send us an email with your enquiries to the company email address below:
Let your dear ones capture beautiful moments by sending them a stylish Digital Camera. Highly popular as a gift, digital cameras of today are equipped with advanced features and are easy to operate. Select a latest digital camera from popular brands like Sony and Canon and it will be safely delivered by a friendly Relationship Ambassador to the door steps of your loved ones.
Mitsubishi WD-73735 73" DLP Projection TV/Nikon D90 Black SLR Digital Camera Kit....
Nikon D300 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-135mm lens.................450 EURO
Nikon D200 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-200mm lens..................400 EURO
Nikon D80 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-55mm lens - supported memory..350 EURO
Nikon D200 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-135mm lens.......300 EURO
Nikon D40 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-55mm lens.........200 EURO
Pentax K10D - body only...................350 EURO
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-W200..................100 EUR
Panasonic Lumix DMC-L10K................. 320 EUR
Canon PowerShot SD850 IS Digital ELPH.....130 EUR
Pentax K110D - PENTAX-DA 18-55mm lens......260 EUR
Canon EOS Digital Rebel XTi - Canon EF-S 18-55mm lens....260 EUR
Panasonic Lumix DMC-L1K....................500 EUR
Canon EOS Digital Rebel XTi - Canon EF-S 18-55mm lens - silver......320 EUR
Nikon D40 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-55mm lens.......245 EUR
Nikon D80 - Nikon AF-S DX 18-135mm lens.......390 EUR
ViewSonic Enterprise Digital Assistant V38R-02a.......515 EUR
MUSICAL INSTRUMENTAL. PIONEER CDJ-800 MP3 MK3 PLAYER PIONEER CDJ-800 MP3 MK2 PLAYER PIONEER DJM 1000 PIONEER DJM 800 PIONEER DJM 600 PIONEER DVJ-X1 DVD PIONEER DVJ-1000 Professional DVD Turntable PIONEER DVJ X1 Professional DVD Turntable Management Contact:
CECT IP1000 @ 200usd
Fujitsu Siemens LOOX T830 @ 300usd
Fujitsu Siemens LOOX N560 @ 2500usd
Gigabyte G-Smart i @ 170usd
Gigabyte G-Smart i120 @ 220usd
Gigabyte G-Smart i300 @ 240usd
Pioneer AVIC-S1 @ $350usd
Pioneer AVIC-Z1 Navigation AVICZ @ $600usd
Pioneer AVIC-N3 Multimedia Navigation Receiver @ $550
Pioneer Avic-z1 Dvd Player Navigation System @ $500usd
Pioneer AVIC-D1 / AVICD1 @ $400usd
Pioneer AVIC-D2 DVD Navigation System @ $400USD
Toshiba IK WB15A IP Network Camera..........260 EURO
Toshiba IK WB21A IP Network PTZ Camera......450 EURO
Canon PowerShot A460........................130 EURO
INTERESTED BUYERS DO CONTACT VIA OUR OFFICIAL EMAIL AT
Email: olaitan_bigtrade@hotmail.com
MSN : olaitan_bigtrade@hotmail.com
KINDLY PLACE YOUR ORDER IN THE BELOW MANNER SO THAT WE CAN
PROCEED ON PACKAGING AND LABELING IMMEDIATELY....
FULL NAME ::
PRODUCTS BRAND AND MODEL ::
QUANTITY ::
ADDRESS ::
CITY ::
ZIP CODE ::
COUNTRY ::
MOBILE/TELEPHONE NUMBER ::
INTERESTED BUYERS DO CONTACT VIA OUR OFFICIAL EMAIL AT
Email: olaitan_bigtrade@hotmail.com
MSN : olaitan_bigtrade@hotmail.com
From AK, 10/20/2008
This has nothing to do with the election. Real Americans, like the parents on my son's hockey team, make their own coffee. They're hardworking blue collar people like you and me. That's why the Maverick and I will only drink coffee made by special needs children while on the campaign trail. You betcha.
From GZ, MB, 09/23/2008
Email: eledealer001@yahoo.com
Email: eledealer@gmail.com
Email: eledealer007@gmail.com
Martin D-45 Dreadnought Acoustic Guitar===============$800usd
Gibson Custom Shop Engraved Les Paul Special - one of a kind Electric
Guitar========$1200usd
Fender Custom Shop Limited Edition Andy Summers Tribute Telecaster Electric
Guitar=====$2000usd
DiPinto Belvedere Deluxe Electric Guitar with Bigsby======$400usd
Jose Ramirez 2CWE Acoustic-Electric Guitar=========$750usd
Jose Ramirez S1 Classical Guitar==========================$500usd
Fender Artist Series J5 Triple Tele Deluxe Electric Guitar====$400usd
Goldtone Weissenborn LM Mahogany Acoustic Guitar==============$250usd
Yamaha AEX 1500 Electric Guitar==============================$500usd
Rodriguez E Spruce Top Classical Guitar==================$600usd
Gretsch Guitars G6122II Chet Atkins Country Gentleman Electric
Guitar====$750usd
DiPinto Belvedere Deluxe Electric Guitar =======$300usd
DiPinto Belvedere Deluxe Electric Guitar =======$550usd
Gretsch Guitars G6122-1959 Chet Atkins Country Gentleman Electric
Guitar=======$900usd
Takamine Concert Classic 132S Acoustic Guitar========$350usd
Hagstrom Jazz Model HJ-500 Semi-Hollow Electric Guitar=====$300usd
Gibson J160E VS STD Modern Classic Acoustic Electric Guitar with Premium
Hardshell Case====1000usd
Hofner 500/1 Vintage '63 Violin Bass Guitar==========$700usd
Jackson RR3 Randy Rhoads Guitar with Gold Pinstripe - Black====$400usd
Martin D41 Special Acoustic Guitar with Case==========$1200usd
Gibson Custom Shop Lattice Roses Engraved Les Paul Special Electric
Guitar=======$1500usd
Martin DC16RGTE Aura Acoustic Electric Guitar with Case======$750usd
Gretsch Guitars G6122-1958 Chet Atkins Country Gentleman Electric
Guitar=====$700usd
Guild GAD-C3 Flamenco Negra Guitar============$300usd
Gibson SG Supreme Electric Guitar with '57 Humbuckers======$800usd
banez RGT42FX RG Fixed Bridge Guitar - Black=======$300usd
lbanez GB15 George Benson Signature Series Hollowbody Electric
Guitar===800usd
Gibson Custom Shop Les Paul Custom Plain Top Electric Guitar====$1000usd
Takamine ESF48C Acoustic-Electric Guitar========$700usd
Jose Ramirez 4E Classical Guitar with Humicase=======$850usd
Gibson Custom Shop Engraved "Dragon" Les Paul Special Single-Cut, one of a
kind electric guitar.=======$3000usd
Alvarez Yairi CY140 Classical Guitar with Case=======$550usd
Taylor GA8-12 Grand Auditorium 12-String Acoustic Guitar====$800usd
Cordoba 55R Classical Guitar with Humicase=============$450usd
Taylor Custom Electric Guitar==================$950usd
Ibanez MTM1 Mick Thomson Signature Series Electric Guitar====$600usd
Gretsch Guitars G6120AM Chet Atkins Hollow Body Flame Maple Top Electric
Guitar============$760usd
Dean The Lost 100 USA Z Classic Black Electric Guitar=====$840usd
Dean The Lost 100 USA Z Classic Black Electric Guitar======$900usd
Dobro Phil Leadbetter Resophonic Guitar============$750usd
Conklin GTBD-7 7 String Bass Guitar============$600usd
Ovation Elite T Series 1778T Acoustic Electric Guitar - Black===$400usd
Ibanez PRB1 Paul Romanko Signature Bass Guitar========$450usd
Hagstrom Jazz Model HL-550 Semi-Hollow Electric Guitar====$350usd
Martin HD-7 Roger McGuinn Acoustic Guitar=========$740usd
Gibson SJ200 True Vintage Acoustic Guitar with Premium Hardshell
Case==$840usd
Fender American Deluxe Stratocaster Electric Guitar====$560usd
Ovation 1771 LX Standard Balladeer Acoustic-Electric Guitar====$670usd
Paul Reed Smith Custom 22 10 Top Electric Guitar========$1100usd
Gretsch Guitars G6120W-1957 Chet Atkins Hollow Body Electric
Guitar====$1000usd
contactusat:-
Email: eledealer001@yahoo.com
Email: eledealer@gmail.com
Email: eledealer007@gmail.com
From Fort Worth, TX, 09/21/2008
"It really seems to be in the Sarah Palin moment. Because all that is about anti-intellectualism and shootin' and huntin' . . . "
That's the stupidest thing I've read in a long time.
From Austin, TX, 09/14/2008
Keith, I completely agree. I rarely go to Starbucks because it is overpriced and coffee shops in general usually appeal to as you say, urban hipsters, or people wanting to feel like they are. There is really nothing intellectual about that. If anything, I would think of these people have more fallen victim to corporate consumerism than the average McDonalds customer. If McDonalds wants to get into the 300+% gross margin coffee business, fine with me.
I agree that anti-intellectualism is a huge problem in this country, but this is not it. If anything it is anti-false-intellectualism, or anti-condescending-attitude.
From Indianapolis, IN, 09/13/2008
I've no issue with these ads because I can see through them; however, I have a problem with those who think McD is doing something unique here. I mean, is having to give away a product, in this case, the coffee (and this is yet another free giveaway by McD to take on SBUX), really challenging a leader? That's the real discussion.
From San Diego, CA, 09/12/2008
This ad isn't making fun of intellectuals, it's making fun of urban hipsters. Of course that's a negative message, but it's hardly anti-intellectualism.
From Merritt Island, FL, 09/12/2008
The problem is an engineered one to promote confusion between having elite people in public office -- the cornerstone of Jeffersonian meritocracy, which should be viewed as a good thing -- and reasonable resentment against elitism.
From Los Angeles, CA, 09/12/2008
It matters because anti-intellectualism in America is a cultural plague. The Framers assumed an educated, thoughtful electorate when they laid the foundations of our democracy, and it's time for intelligent people to say, "Enough!" Enough of choosing candidates it might be fun to have a beer with, enough allowing althetes to bully the smart kids in high school, enough making fun of intelligence/cosmopolitanism/intellectual curiosity in our public discourse, whether serious or, as in this ad, lightheartedly for humor. Who were the great anti-intellectuals of the last century? Hitler and Stalin and Mao. It's oh-so-much-more subtle here, but do we really want to play in that sandbox? I sincerely hope Popcorn is right and this campaign fails.
09/12/2008
Why anybody is surprised about this development is a puzzle to me. Politics and corporatism have slowly crept into one another for over a quarter century now; why should advertising be any exception? Hatred sells; as writers like Jacques Ellul have pointed out, propaganda (read: advertising) MUST insinuate itself into all aspects of human life. As fatalistic as this may sound, no one can, much less will, do anything to alleviate its poisonous reach. Only an ethics and practice of renunciation will save people--something neither of these companies wants to flourish.
From NC, 09/11/2008
As stated in the article, this ad campaign has been going on long before elitism became an issue in the presidential campaign. Interviewing people angry about the Palin pick makes it seem like a much more charged issue than it should be. McDonalds is merely trying to reach people turned off by the Starbucks culture. It has nothing to do with the campaigns and is just making the lighthearted point that we don't have to feel awkward in order to drink coffee.
I agree that it's sad to watch America's disgust for intellectualism, but can we just have a laugh at an add that is meant to be humorous? People taking offense to things like this (and the media legitimizing it) is part of the reason why this election has gotten so ridiculous.
09/11/2008
McDonald's is attacking jazz? Oh yes, I'd much rather sit in a hard plastic booth listening to soft rock and stuffing my face with a big mac! Last time I checked, a cup of COFFEE at Starbucks is well under $2...it only gets expensive when you add milk and espresso and flavors and everything. And Starbucks at least attempts to do some good in the world, while McDonald's is plowing down the rain forest to make room for genetically-engineered cows. Why is it bad to be intelligent? Intellectual? To like music that values talent and creativity over mass marketing and the lowest common denominator. It's just disgusting!
Post a Comment: Please be civil, brief and relevant.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. Marketplace reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air if they are extra-interesting. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to American Public Media. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited email and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.