Scraping by while unemployed
The national unemployment rate has reached a depressing 9%, but states like Oregon and South Carolina have it even worse. We talk to unemployed workers from these states to see how they're making ends meet.
Clockwise from top left: Diedre Murphy, Nathaniel Sullivan, Clorene Jones and Michael Dymond. (Courtesy of pictured)
Links
- Audio: Michael Dymond, 40, welder (Portland, Ore.)
Each week on Marketplace Money, host Tess Vigeland looks at the week's major national and international stories that will impact the average listener's wallet. - Audio: Diedre Murphy, 47, marketing manager (Blythewood, S.C.)
Each week on Marketplace Money, host Tess Vigeland looks at the week's major national and international stories that will impact the average listener's wallet. - Audio: Clorene Jones, 79, Textile worker (Greenville, S.C. )
Each week on Marketplace Money, host Tess Vigeland looks at the week's major national and international stories that will impact the average listener's wallet. - Audio: Nathaniel Sullivan, 57, Textile worker (Greenville, S.C.)
Each week on Marketplace Money, host Tess Vigeland looks at the week's major national and international stories that will impact the average listener's wallet. - Very different states of unemployment
- State unemployment funds go bust
- Voices and Images: Oregonians and South Carolinians talk about the challenges of high unemployment
- ProPublica Story: Unemployment Insurance Is Not Working
- ProPublica Map: Is Your State's Unemployment System in Danger?
TEXT OF STORY
TESS VIGELAND:We've already mentioned the national unemployment rate topped nine percent last month. And it sounds pretty awful. But not compared to what's going on in some states.
Michigan has the highest rate at just over 13 percent. Oregon's next at 12 percent. South Carolina's third at just over 11 percent. Today throughout the show we'll hear from several workers in those last two states. They're all trying to make it on a mix of unemployment benefits, savings and whatever else they can cobble together.
We start in Oregon.
Michael Dymond: Michael Dymond and I'm 40 years old and I work as a welder. Last nine years I've been working for Gunderson, a rail car manufacturing company, and they hit pretty big down streak.
My weekly at Gunderson, somewhere around $600 and when I'm on unemployment, it's about $425. You know $425 a week is just scraping by. I've got three kids at home, I have a fiancee at home and we just barely get by. Bills and loans for the rent or the house payments and the electric and the utilities, they're just outrageous. Every time I go on unemployment, I fall behind on bills. The financial backing as far as unemployment itself, it's so lacking, it's almost impossible to live on it, while you're trying to look for a job.
I went there for resume classes and I've never had a resume before. I went to two classes, I had to repeat one just so I could figure out what they're talking about and it's just so far above my head, seeing I've never seen a resume, I don't even know where to begin.
Deidre Murphy: I'm Deidre Murphy. I live in Blythewood, S.C. and I'm 47. I was in marketing. I was making, gosh with benefits and everything and with bonus, about $95,000. I got $326 a week, which is the absolute maximum in South Carolina. If I cobbled all four of those checks together, I could pay my mortgage. I have zero savings left. I did everything I could to pay my mortgage, to protect my credit and now that I've been unemployed for so long, I'm not eligible for any of these wonderful mortgage programs. So yeah, I'm a little angry, to be perfectly honest.
You know, I didn't feel like it was my fault that I got laid off at all. It had nothing to do with my job performance. My ego started taking a hit, when I started getting rejected everywhere I was looking for a job. I would either hear nothing or I'd get an actually rejection. Then you start hearing every week the numbers of who was getting laid off and then, I'm talking to all these people, everybody I know knows somebody who's been laid off.
Clorene Jones: I'm Clorene Jones, Greensboro, S.C. I worked in a weave mill for 46 years. Last March of 2008, the place that I worked closed down. Hadn't worked too long. I hadn't been back to work, but not quite a year, but I did get some unemployment, $193 a week. And then I've drawn up Social Security too, that helps.
Well I had a job to go to another plant, but when I went, because I didn't have a GED or a diploma, they wouldn't hire me. I finished the 10th grade when I was going to school. Well some of it I find hard, especially the algebra part of it. I wasn't too good in school, it's real hard.
Nathaniel Sullivan: My name is Nathaniel Sullivan, I'm 57 years old. I'm trying to get my GED and further my education. My last job was at Delta Mills, it was 2006 I worked for a textile company. And they moved overseas.
When the job ended, i think I was making about $12 an hour. My unemployment started, I think, a week or two after the job ended. It was a third of the amount of money I was making. It made life a little different, you know what I mean? I worked a lot of overtime, I had to budget a lot more than I normally would.
My benefits ended four weeks ago. It's scary, you know what I mean? I'm a single man, I have to live and that's like no money right now. It's a scary feeling really. The economy is even scarier, because you know, I got other friends that are looking for jobs and they've been looking for jobs for months and they still don't have any employment. I've worked in manufacturing all my life and that's one job I don't want, but the type of job I think that I'd really enjoy would have something to do with computers. It's kind of hard, because my money's end and I need some more schooling to achieve that.
Vigeland: Our profiles of unemployed folks in South Carolina and Oregon were produced by Mitchell Hartman in collaboration with the investigative newsroom ProPublica.
Comments
Comment | Refresh
06/12/2009
Ms. Hill, according to Ms. Murphy, her $95k income included benefits and bonuses. She apparently did save, as she said her savings ran out. I did not read the part about her having a big house, car, etc. Yours seems an unfounded judgment that happens often during this time of economic uncertainty. Do you know that she too is not a single mother?
I agree that our culture of hyper-consumerism shares a blame, but it is interesting that you do not see the other people's failure to obtain even a GED as part of the problem. No one is completely blameless for the mess we are in.
06/08/2009
I feel sorry for most of the people who were interviewed for this piece, except for Deidre Murphy. She has an education and should have been smart enough to put away some money for a rainly day. How long was she making $95,000 per year? Why doesn't she have any savings? I make half that and am a single parent, but I have enough put away to see me through 6-9 months of unemployment.
I think people like her are a big reason this country is facing such a fiscal crisis. For decades people have lived way beyond their means, living in huge houses, driving new cars and having to have everything right now. Maybe the only way we'll ever truly get out of this mess is if we can learn to save and not have to be such a consumer driven society.
From Richmond, CA, 06/06/2009
I hope you would investigate a malfeasance by California EDD with respect to Federal Unemployment Extensions.
I believe they have violated the rules/guidelines of the Federal Dept. of Labor, which requires that the states that administer UI disclose the essential criteria of eligibility for extensions.
The result must be that many, such as myself, were blindsided -unexpectedly and suddenly denied benefits.
Such disclosure is critical because the eligibility criteria are different than the standard criteria. Some states do a proper job of disclosure; California does not. It is a simple correction and adjustment to accomplish this.
I have saved various website addresses and other documentation if you care to address the issue.
Evan Blickenstaff
evanblick@earthlink.net
510.868.0820
Post a Comment: Please be civil, brief and relevant.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. Marketplace reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air if they are extra-interesting. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to American Public Media. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited email and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.