What can be done to stop world hunger
The Wall Street Journal's Roger Thurow, co-author of the book "Enough," talks with Kai Ryssdal about why the markets may be impeding getting food to poor countries, and what may help.
Wall Street Journal reporter Roger Thurow (themayborn.unt.edu)
More on Charity - Giving, Bookshelf, Food
TEXT OF INTERVIEW
Kai Ryssdal: Along with global warming and a world-wide recession, leaders at the G8 summit this week are going to talk about agriculture. Specifically, aid for farmers in poor countries to help them grow more food. In a new book called "Enough," Wall Street Journal reporter Roger Thurow says there's more that needs to be done to solve world hunger than just growing more food. Welcome to the program.
ROGER THUROW: Thanks for having me.
Ryssdal: You know, I think probably most of us would guess that hunger and famine in this world are natural phenomena. That they are the results of droughts and poor planting seasons. You and your co-author, though, make a different case -- entirely. That it's all bad politics, really, and broken markets.
THUROW: Yeah, that so much of today's hunger is caused by bad policy that spans the political spectrum. And policies that may have started off with good intentions, say our farm subsidies, food aid, ethanol incentives.
Ryssdal: It sorta sounds as if you're saying for all the good that the West, and specifically the United States, tries to do in the area of food aid, getting food over there, giving hundreds of millions of dollars every year to people who need it, really it's a little bit backwards.
THUROW: The U.S. food aid system as it's started and as it is now, it's 100 percent American-grown food shipped on American-flagged ships. There is no flexibility, or very little flexibility, for using cash to buy food that may be available in the hunger-stricken countries themselves or in the region. And as we described in the book, kinda the classic situation where this arose, and basically got people to really think about this, was the famine of Ethiopia of 2003.
That famine was proceeded by two years of some of the best crops that Ethiopian farmers had ever had. After those two great years of harvest, prices collapsed 80 percent. So a lot of the food remained in some warehouses of local traders. So in that situation, here comes all this American food aid streaming into the country, but it was coming on the road from the point in Djibouti, right past some of the warehouses that were pretty much full to the roof with Ethiopian-grown food that there was no market for, that there was no money to buy up the surplus crops that were still available.
Ryssdal: I wanna make that point again. Ethiopia can feed itself. But the markets don't let that system work.
THUROW: Exactly. So what happened in the famine of 2003 is that the markets failed before the weather did.
Ryssdal: You know, you have a great line in the book. You say, quoting some people in Ethiopia, they say, "I don't care if it rains in Ethiopia, so long as it rains in Iowa." The assumption being, you know, that's where the corn that is going to feed us is being grown.
THUROW: Right, and it really creates this dependency syndrome. That instead of the Ethiopian farmers having the incentive to grow as much as possible, there's this thinking in the back of their minds, well, there's the food aid that is going to come in.
Ryssdal: Is there anything on the international scene that's going to break that cycle?
THUROW: With President Obama, minutes into his administration, in his inaugural address, he addressed the poor nations of the world, and he said, "We will work to make your farms flourish and clean water flow." To make your farms flourish, that's what we're talking about in terms of the agricultural development that's been so sorely neglected. There's a grassroots movement that's coming from churches, and temples, and synagogues, from universities, and from philanthropies, like the Gates Foundation. I think this awareness and this pressure coming from the grassroots is beginning to grab the attention of the statesman and political leaders more. There is leadership on this.
Ryssdal: Roger Thurow writes for the Wall Street Journal. He and his colleague have a new book out about global hunger and international food aid. It's called "Enough." Roger, thanks a lot.
THUROW: Thank you very much.
Comments
Comment | Refresh
07/14/2009
Hi Kai, the major problem of Ethiopia is not hunger it is very lack of democratic administration. The Ethiopian people still poor for long time because of selfish dictator and especially right now only the party members as a chain from top rich to middle class had shared aid money, but 85% peoples in sad situation even for a slice of bread. President Obama Administration should or must be say enough is enough go back to Ghana democracy style election, and release oppositions jailed over 20,000 people and tight with intellegencey the right to speak and free median after fraud of election 2005.
For instance, the aid money supplied by the United States President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) was $48 million for FY 2004, $83.7 million for FY2005, $123 million for FY2006, $241.8 million for FY2007and $354.5 million for FY2008. This smooth flow of money is just the tip of the iceberg, compared to what Ethiopia gets in aid money from other programs such as the ones sponsored by Global Fund to Fight AIDS, TB and Malaria ($1,107,164,389) and another millions of dollars from the US Center for Disease Control and Prevention CDC.
Look Kai; the flow of this aid money is controlled by the prime minister and his wife!
Peter
From Seattle, WA, 07/09/2009
"I don't care if it rains in Ethiopia, so long as it rains in Iowa." This not a good quote from any open minded.
Kia, I am your long listener, and you need to raise key question is the aid money directly goes to 80% poor Ethiopians or to the pocket of military dictator stay in power after fraud of election in 2005. What about if the military government tries a dam from Blue Nile base of river start from Ethiopia and it flown to nine neighboring countries instead of depending on natural rain. The U.S. or developed nation should tell them in plain English to Africa leader to value human and how democracy is sweet, but they prefer always hate and war ethics to divert the attention of the world.
You know Kia, I love your program everyday, and I like to tell you that Africa Leaders are know very well a bout democracy in theory than President Obama, but the don't want to implement practically for ever; even to follow the best Ghana democracy style from Africa. So, when is democracy and sustainable development comes to Africa?
Thank you guys for your concern.
Solomon
From Phoenixville, PA, 07/09/2009
A very important story to tell. Unfortunately, the story goes back many years. See economist D. Gale Johnson's book World Agriculture in Disarray. Unfortunately, politics will likely continue to hamper a solution. The last administration attempted to move to buy food aid regionally, but as I understand it, due to the powerful farm lobby, it went no where.
From Marcellus, MI, 07/09/2009
Your very brief story on the book "Enough" was refreshing. It would be nice if all of your reporting was done from the perspective of this book--less cheerleading for the status quo and more critical analysis of what is and has always been wrong with world markets, and how the majority of the people on this planet are not justly served by them.
Post a Comment: Please be civil, brief and relevant.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. Marketplace reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air if they are extra-interesting. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to American Public Media. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited email and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.