Marketplace

Search

Friday, October 16, 2009

Listen to the show

Economy hits elderly immigrants hard

Elderly immigrants

Elderly immigrants are being forced to postpone retirement because of the recession. But they're having trouble finding work, and get little in the way of government assistance. Jeff Tyler reports.

Filipino-American veterans who fought with U.S. troops in World War II. Elderly immigrants like them are now struggling to find work in the United States. (Jeff Tyler / Marketplace)

More on Immigration, America's Financial Crisis

  • Gerry "Ray" Geronimo standing outside at the office of the Filipino American Service Group. Geronimo is a legal immigrant in the United States, but can't find work and doesn't receive Social Security benefits.

    Gerry "Ray" Geronimo standing outside at the office of the Filipino American Service Group. Geronimo is a legal immigrant in the United States, but can't find work and doesn't receive Social Security benefits.

TEXT OF STORY

TESS VIGELAND: The unemployment rate for adults over age 65 has doubled since the recession began. Elderly immigrants are especially vulnerable. They have a small safety net to start with. On top of it all, legal immigrants don't get much in the way of government assistance.

Marketplace's Jeff Tyler visited some immigrant communities here in Southern California and shares their stories with us.


Jeff Tyler: These elderly Filipino-Americans get together once a week to socialize. At a senior center in Los Angeles, they talk about having to make do with less. California's statewide budget cuts have reduced their supplemental income benefits. But at least they collect something.

Gerry Geronimo is 69 years old, but he doesn't get Social Security.

Gerry Geronimo: No. Not yet. I'm not yet citizen. Three more years.

He is a legal immigrant. Geronimo and his wife waited a long time for green cards.

Geronimo: Twenty-three long years we waited for the petition.

In the Philippines, Geronimo says, companies won't hire seniors.

Geronimo: You can't work. At the age of 60, you have to retire.

In the U.S., he qualifies to work, but struggles to find the opportunities.

Geronimo: I want to find a job.

He works part-time in a job-training program. Because of the economy, his hours have been cut. Together with his wife's income, they bring in less than $1,000 a month. His sister-in-law was supposed to sponsor them and help them financially. But instead, Geronimo is paying all the bills.

Geronimo: The electricity, the gas, and the water bill. She has no money at all.

As a young man in Manila, he adopted the name "Ray" and worked as a DJ.

Geronimo: 99.5 RDD, your DJ, Ray Geronimo.

He applied for a job at a Filipino radio station in Los Angeles, but hasn't heard back yet.

Other elderly immigrants come here to work in the home. They look after grand kids -- saving the family money on child care -- while the parents work at minimum wage jobs.

Steven Wallace is UCLA professor of public health, who studies trends in immigration. He says the recession has caused job losses for some two-income families, cutting their income in half. But at the same time, they still have that extra person to support.

Steven Wallace: As a result of having to stretch the dollars even further, the poverty rate among immigrant elders is higher than the poverty rate among elders as a whole.

Many elderly immigrants tend to feel responsible for the financial welfare of the extended family.

Susan Dilkes runs a social services agency in Los Angeles helping elderly Filipinos.

Susan Dilkes: In our country, the elderly are the breadwinners. They support their children. And then when they come here, and they're staying with their children, they really feel that they're a burden to them.

Only about 20 percent of U.S. immigrants arrive after the age of 50. Most transplants come as young adults. But UCLA professor Steven Wallace says, young immigrants who grow old here are often not much better off.

Wallace: Most immigrants who come to the United States are in low-wage industries. So when they retire, they don't have pensions; they don't have savings.

Wallace says immigrants need to work in the U.S. on the books for 10 years before they can claim federal benefits.

Wallace: So if you're cleaning houses and you worked for cash for 30 years and never reported that income to Social Security, you would retire with no pension, and no eligibility for Social Security or SSI.

In addition to the financial hurdles, elderly immigrants also face cultural challenges.

The recent Pacific Islander Festival in Huntington Beach was like a Polynesian battle of the bands -- showcasing the cultures of Fiji, Samoa, Tahiti, and other islands. Old-country traditions are a source of pride. But elderly immigrants, steeped in those cultures, can also feel cut-off.

Greta Briand with the Pacific Islander Health Partnership works with seniors from the Marshall Islands.

Greta Briand: They cannot speak the language. So they need to have someone to go with them anywhere they want to go.

Some seniors reach the conclusion that the grass was greener in the old country. Faifua Vaifale says seniors miss the island life.

Faifua Vaifale: They want to go back home because, back home, you know, a lot of things are free.

In the U.S., you need in a job and money to survive. She says, in Samoa, seniors can feed themselves with just a fishing pole.

In Huntington Beach, I'm Jeff Tyler for Marketplace Money.

Comments

  • Comment | Refresh

  • By daniel law

    From las vegas, NV, 10/19/2009

    I know it may sound reactionary or isolationist, and I certainly don't wish anyone ill, but I have to say, "Boo hoo for them." They only have to pay into Social Security ten years to get benefits. I've paid in all my working life (I'm 61). I don't think ten years is long enough for them to receive the same benefits as someone like me.

    As far as future plans go, my feeling is that we should stop immigration until our own citizens begin to regain a more solid foothold financially.

    I know all the lines about all of us were immigrants once except Native Americans, etc. But times change and if we don't change our immigration policies, we'll continue to lose ground.

  • Post a Comment: Please be civil, brief and relevant.

    Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. Marketplace reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air if they are extra-interesting. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.

    * indicates required field

    *
    *
    *
     




     

    You must be 13 or over to submit information to American Public Media. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited email and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Music From This Show

  • Dream Seasons Blackalicious Buy
  • Warning Sign Talking Heads Buy
  • Hanuman Rodrigo y Gabriela Buy
  • As Time Goes By Henry Mancini Buy
  • No Growing Olivia Tremor Control Buy
  • Money in the Pocket Cannonball Adderley Buy
Podcast »

Listen to 'After the Bell'

In his weekly podcast, Scott Jagow makes sense of the week in business and the economy. Subscribe now.

The Whiteboard »

Hostile takeovers

Hostile TakeoversWatch the video

We all know what a takeover is. That's when one company agrees to be bought by another. But what happens when companies don't agree and the takeover goes hostile? Senior Editor Paddy Hirsch explains. Watch the video.

More Whiteboard Videos »

Getting Personal »
Chris Farrell

Q: Income-based student loans

You recently reported on a student loan option that was being offered as part of the government stimulus package, which is based on a person's income.... I was wondering if you could please let me know where to find this information. Thanks. Ethan, Minneapolis, MN Read Chris Farrell's answer »

Special Reports and Series

Built on Belief »

One year after the fall of Lehman Brothers, Americans' have lost faith in the financial system and learned some hard lessons. Get more.

The Big Shift »

The recession has changed our financial lives. A look at wealth and prosperity in the middle class and how we live now. Get more.

The Borrowers »

How living beyond our means helped bring down the economy. The role of personal debt in the financial crisis, and where we go from here. Get more.

The Next American Dream »

How four pillars of the American Dream are changing. What's in your future?

Taking Stock »

Conversations with individuals who can give us the long view of our economic situation. Get their views.

More Stories & Special Reports »

The Specials

GAME: Budget Hero

Budget Hero

Think you could balance the federal budget? Play the game.

Conversations from the Corner OfficeTM

Conversations From the Corner Office

Marketplace goes one-on-one with CEOs, company founders, head honchos...

Sit in

Working

Working

Intimate profiles of workers in the global economy.

Meet them

Marketplace on iTunes U

iTunes U

Marketplace is on Apple's online education platform, iTunesU. Get free downloads in subjects like History, Science, Business and more. Study up

American Public Media © |   Terms and Conditions   |   Privacy Policy